Attachment request

This document pretains to SAT-MOD-20090429-00047 for Modification on a Satellite Space Stations filing.

IBFS_SATMOD2009042900047_710545

pillsbury Pillsbury Winthrop Shaw Pittman LLP 2300 N Street, NW | Washington, DC 20037—1122 | tel 202.663.8000 | fax 202.663.8007 Bruce D. Jacobs tel 202.663.8077 bruce.jacobs@pillsburylaw.com | FORINTERNAL USE ONLY | April 30, 2009 [ | f» NON—PLUBLIG By Hand Delivery © Marlene H. Dortch Federal Communications Commission APR 3 0 20 445 1_2“‘ Street, S.W. FEGETA! COMIRUpine n 09 Washington, DC 20554 Ofice ofthsgoct.Ctmisgign Tétary Re: REQUEST FOR CONFIDENTIAL TREATMENT Confidential Appendix SkyTerra Subsidiary LLC File Nos. SAT—MOD—20090429—00046 SAT—MOD—20090429—00047 SES—MOD—20090429—00536 Dear Ms. Dortch: SkyTerra Subsidiary LLC ("SkyTerra") hereby requests confidential treatment for the attached document (hereafter "Confidential Appendix") submitted in connection with the above—referenced modification applications to SkyTerra‘s authority to operate an Ancillary Terrestrial Component ("ATC") in the L band.‘ The Confidential Appendix contains information pertaining to SkyTerra‘s international L—band frequency coordination agreements and the status of negotiations with other L—band operators. Consistent with Commission precedent, the information should be treated as confidential." If disclosed, it would violate confidentiality agreements with those operators and prejudice negotiations. This would undermine the ability of SkyTerra to obtain optimal use of the L—band spectrum, resulting in substantial competitive harm to SkyTerra. Moreover, disclosure of the Confidential Appendix ‘ A copy of this request for confidential treatment without the Confidential Appendix is being filed in the public record. * See Robert J. Butler, 6 FCC Red 5414 (1991); In the Matter ofAmendment ofthe Commission‘s Rules to Establish Rules and Policies Pertaining to a Non—voice, Non—Geostationary Mobile Satellite Service, 8 FCC Red 8450, at [ 10 (1993); Comsat Corporation d/b/a Comsat Mobile Communications, et al., 16 FCC Red 21661, at §« 110—11 (2001). [FOR INTERNAL USE ONLY ’ | NON—PUBLC

Marlene H. Dortch April 30, 2009 Page 2 would undermine the ability of the United States, as SkyTerra‘s licensing administration, to conclude and maintain coordination agreements with other administrations." For these reasons, SkyTerra submits that the Commission should grant this request for confidential treatment. In conformity with Section 0.459(b) of the Commission‘s rules, SkyTerra submits the following: 47 C.F.R. § 0.459(b)(1) —— Identification of the specific information for which confidential treatment is sought SkyTerra seeks confidential treatment of the information contained in the attached Confidential Appendix, pertaining to SkyTerra‘s international L—band frequency coordination agreements and the status of negotiations with other L—band operators. 47 C.F.R. § 0.459(b)(2) —— Identification of the Commission proceeding in which the information was submitted or a description of the circumstances giving rise to the submission The information contained in the Confidential Appendix is being submitted in connection with SkyTerra‘s modification applications to operate an ATC in the L band. See File Nos. SAT—MOD—20090429—00046, SAT—MOD—20090429—00047, SES—MOD—20090429—00536. 47 C.F.R. § 0.459(b)(3) ~— Explanation of the degree to which the information is commercial or financial, or contains a trade secret or is privileged The Confidential Appendix contains information pertaining to SkyTerra‘s international L—band frequency coordination agreements and the status of negotiations with other L—band operators. That information is relevant to the amount of SkyTerra‘s authorized and internationally coordinated spectrum, which impacts SkyTerra‘s commercial and financial interests.*‘ As the Commission has concluded, such information is also confidential because its disclosure would adversely affect the ability of the United States, as SkyTerra‘s licensing administration, to negotiate L—band spectrum on SkyTerra‘s behalf.‘ * See Robert J. Butler, at "| 14. * See Robert J. Butler, at « 12. * Id. at | 13 (documents related to L—band coordination meeting are "privileged or confidential" because disclosure would "hamper the United States‘ ability to engage in successful MSS negotiations with the other entities and countries proposing MSS systems, for which the United States might develop a different negotiation strategy."). 401189054v2v3

Marlene H. Dortch April 30, 2009 Page 3 47 C.F.R. § 0.459(b)(4) —— Explanation of the degree to which the information concerns a service that is subject to competition The information contained in the Confidential Appendix concerns the market for satellite and wireless services, in which SkyTerra faces competition from Mobile Satellite Service providers and terrestrial wireless operators. 47 C.F.R. § 0.459(b)(5) ~— Explanation of how disclosure of the information could result in substantial competitive harm Disclosure of the Confidential Appendix would result in substantial competitive harm. The Confidential Appendix contains information pertaining to SkyTerra‘s international L—band frequency coordination agreements and the status of negotiations with other L—band operators, and SkyTerra‘s negotiating strategies. If disclosed, it would prejudice negotiations in international coordination with other operators. This would undermine the ability of SkyTerra (and the United States) to obtain optimal use of the L—band spectrum, resulting in substantial competitive harm to SkyTerra." 47 C.F.R. § 0.459(b)(6) —— Identification of any measures taken by the submitting party to prevent unauthorized disclosure SkyTerra has limited the distribution of the information contained in the Confidential Appendix to authorized employees and agents. Additionally, as the Commission has recognized, the terms of coordination agreements are confidential to the parties to the agreements." * See Robert J. Butler, at 15 (disclosure of information concerning L—band coordination meeting would limit ability of the parties to adopt different negotiating positions in other L—band coordination meetings, adversely affecting their ability to obtain the optimal amount of spectrum to conduct business successfully). " See, eg., Comsat Corporation d/b/a Comsat Mobile Communications, et al., 16 FCC Red 21661, at 4 110—11 (2001) ("The Mexico City Agreement and related coordination documents, such as minutes of coordination meetings, are considered confidential."). 401189054v2v3

Marlene H. Dortch April 30, 2009 Page 4 47 C.F.R. § 0.459(b)(7) —— Identification of whether the information is available to the public and the extent of any previous disclosure of the information to third parties The information contained in the Confidential Appendix has not been made available to the public or disclosed to unauthorized third parties. 47 C.F.R. § 0.459(b)(8) —— Justification of the period during which the submitting party asserts that material should not be available for public disclosure There is no benefit to be derived from public disclosure of the Confidential Appendix. But, as discussed above, there is the potential for substantial harm to SkyTerra if disclosed. Therefore, the Confidential Appendix should be withheld permanently from public disclosure. 47 C.F.R. § 0.459(b)(9) —— Any other information that the party seeking confidential treatment believes may be useful in assessing whether its request for confidentiality should be granted Other foreign operators and administrations expect that coordination agreements and discussions are conducted in private and held in confidence.‘ Accordingly, disclosure of the information contained in the Confidential Appendix would impair the ability of the United States in the future to conclude coordination agreements with other administrations, which would be discouraged from negotiating openly. For these reasons, the Commission should grant the request for confidential treatment. Please contact the undersigned with any questions. Very truly yours, Bruce D. Jacobs Tony Lin co: (w/confidential attachment) Robert Nelson Kathyrn Medley William Bell 8 See Robert J. Butler, at " 14. 401189054v2v3


Document Created: 2019-04-15 19:39:48
Document Modified: 2019-04-15 19:39:48
© 2024 FCC.report
This site is not affiliated with or endorsed by the FCC