Attachment 2003TMI Mobile-Carri

2003TMI Mobile-Carri

Ex PARTE PRESENTATION NOTIFICATION LETTER submitted by "the Carriers"

ex parte

2003-11-28

This document pretains to SAT-MOD-20020717-00117 for Modification on a Satellite Space Stations filing.

IBFS_SATMOD2002071700117_805619

                                                     AP TE  O! LA~T
                                                                  TEe 5J EJLY
                                                                      PlLE                        OR‘GINAL
                                                    PA RT E ON




                                                      J
                                            _ Z4R
                                           /



WILKINSON ) BARKER ) KNAUER | LLP                                                                2500 N $rkee3, NW
                                                                 ?Egi{"éiw & 5                   suite 700
                                                                  wa"   B &   l     AE«          wasHincton, DC 20037

                                                                                                 TEL    202.783.4141

                                                                                                 FAX    202.783.5851

                                                                                                 w w w . w bklaw. c o m




                                                                        RECEIVED
    November 28, 2003                                                     DEC — 1 2003
                                                                 FEDEARAL COMMUNICATIONS c:::MSSXON
                                                                          OFFICE OF THE SECRET         I nt,'l Bureau
    g/lez:;leetl;:yH. Dortch

    Federal Communications Commission                                                                     DEC 0 4 2003
    445 12th Street, S.W.                                                                                                 .
    Washington, D.C. 20554                                                                                Front Office

                       Ro:     Oral Ex Parte Presentation

                               TMI Communications and Company, Limited Partnership, DA 03—385,
                               File Nos. 189—SAT—LOI—97 et al.; Mobile Communications Holdings, Inc.,
                               DA 03—285, File No. SAT—T/C—20020719—00104 et al.; Constellation
                               Communications Holdings, Inc., DA 03—285, File No. SAT—T/C—
                               20020718—00104 et al.; Globalstar, L.P., DA 03—328, File Nos.
                               183/184/185/186—SAT—P/LA—97 et al.

   Dear Ms. Dortch:

           On November 25, 2003, Doug Brandon of AT&T Wireless Services, Inc. and Jim Bugel
   of Cingular Wireless LLC (the "Carriers"), together with the undersigned, met with Paul Margie,
   Legal Advisor to Commissioner Michael Copps, to discuss the 2 GHz MSS authorization
   applications for review identified above. During the meeting, the Carriers addressed issues
   previously raised in response to applicants.‘ In particular, the Carriers discussed the
   Commussion‘s strict milestone enforcement policy, the straightforward nature of the initial
   milestone requirement, and the International Bureau‘s decisions correctly concluding that the
   authorizations at issue were null and void for failure to comply with the milestone.

           With respect to TMI Communications and Company, Limited Partnership ("TMI"), the
   Carriers noted that the back—to—back nature of the contractual arrangements did not satisfy the

   \ See e. g., Letter to Marlene H. Dortch, Secretary, FCC from Kathryn A. Zachem et a/., File Nos. 189—SAT—LOI—97
   et al. (Aug. 8, 2003); Letter to Marlene H. Dortch, Secretary, FCC from Kathryn A. Zachem et a/., File Nos. 189—
   SAT—LOI—97 et al. (June 20, 2003); AT&T Wireless et al., Opposition to Application for Review, File No. 189—
   SAT—LOI—97 et al. (Mar. 27, 2003); AT&T Wireless et al., Opposition to Joint Application for Review, File No.
   SAT—T/C—20020719—00104 et al. (Mar. 18, 2003); AT&T Wireless et al., Opposition to Emergency Application for
   Review, File Nos. 183/184/185/186—SAT—P/LA—97 et al. (Mar. 18, 2003)
                                                                                                 i\"\ of         e :'\643’,‘5__Q~tg
                                                                                                 List A


Wirkinson ) BarkER] KNAUER| LLP
    Marlene H. Dortch |
    November 28, 2003
    Page 2

    milestone and that TMI failed to take steps, such as entering a non—contingent contract with an
    assignability provision, which would have satisfied the milestone. With respect to Mobile
    Communications Holdings, Inc. and Constellation Communications Holdings, Inc., the Carriers
    again emphasized that the proposed satellite sharing arrangements with ICO Global
    Communications (Holdings) Limited failed to satisfy the letter and spirit of the noncontingent
    contract milestone. With respect to Globalstar, L.P., the Carriers noted that the contract upon
    which Globalstar relied did not allow for completion of the satellite system and certification of
    full operations within the milestones, thus violating the requirements of the initial milestone.

             Please contact the undersigned with any questions.

                                                         Respectfully submitted,


                                                         Cie 2
                                                         Kathryn A. Zachem
                                                         Adam D. Krinsky




    ce:      Paul Margie
             Donald Abelson
             Thomas Tycz
             Anna Gomez
             Jackie Ruff
             Howard Griboff
             Jennifer Gilsenan
             Karl Kensinger
             Roderick Porter
             John Rogovin
             David Horowitz
             Neil Dellar



Document Created: 2019-04-09 21:40:45
Document Modified: 2019-04-09 21:40:45

© 2024 FCC.report
This site is not affiliated with or endorsed by the FCC